On April 24, 2026, MyFitnessPal pushed a major redesign. The old Diary tab — the home screen that millions of users had muscle memory for — was replaced with a new "Today" view. The food diary was buried behind a "View All" button. Per-meal macro breakdowns got harder to find. Swipe-between-days navigation disappeared.
MyFitnessPal's response? The new design is "the path forward" and there is no option to revert.
"The diary has been ruined by being converted to a list of gigantic, space-consuming cards. Logging a full day's food now takes noticeably more effort than before." — App Store reviewer, April 2026
This isn't the first time MFP has frustrated its users. The October 2025 update broke the ability to copy and paste meals, removed bulk delete, and collapsed meal entries by default. The macro goal bug — where custom macros reset themselves immediately after saving — has been reported since July 2025 and remains unfixed. Garmin and Fitbit syncs have broken intermittently for over a year.
And then there's the pricing. MyFitnessPal Premium now runs about $80 USD per year. Barcode scanning — once free — has been a Premium-only feature since 2022.
Why this keeps happening
In 2020, Under Armour sold MyFitnessPal to private equity firm Francisco Partners for $345 million. Since then, the app has followed a predictable PE playbook: monetise existing users more aggressively, acquire competitors (Cal AI in early 2026, meal planning app Intent before that, a ChatGPT Health integration in January 2026), and deprioritise the product fundamentals that built the user base in the first place.
The April 2026 redesign is the most visible symptom of a deeper shift: MFP is no longer optimising for the person trying to track their food. It's optimising for engagement metrics, Premium conversion, and AI feature launches.
What users are actually complaining about
According to community forums and App Store reviews from April–May 2026: food diary buried (most common), week starting on Sunday by default (calendar preference removed), no swipe between days, bold text choices that feel visually jarring, nutritional data harder to surface quickly.
What users are switching to
The Reddit thread on r/MyFitnessPal from April 24 has thousands of comments. The recurring alternatives mentioned: Cronometer (for micronutrient depth), Lose It (for simplicity), and increasingly, AI-native apps that don't require database searching at all.
The frustration isn't just about this redesign. It's about a pattern. MFP has now had two major updates in six months that made the core logging experience worse. At some point, staying loyal to an app that keeps making itself harder to use stops being a reasonable choice.
What to look for in a replacement
If you're switching, the features that matter most for long-term consistency are: logging speed (how many taps or seconds does a meal take?), friction on unusual foods (what happens when you eat something that isn't in a database?), coaching beyond the data (does the app help you understand what your numbers mean?), and pricing transparency (no surprise paywalls on features you relied on).
The best alternative isn't necessarily the one with the biggest database. It's the one you'll actually use every day — because consistency matters far more than precision.
Common questions
What changed in the MyFitnessPal April 2026 redesign?
MyFitnessPal replaced its Diary tab with a new Today screen, burying the food log behind a View All button. Per-meal macro breakdowns became harder to find, swipe-between-days was removed, and MFP confirmed there is no rollback option.
Why are people leaving MyFitnessPal in 2026?
Users cite the April 2026 redesign making logging harder, paywall creep on features like barcode scanning, a macro goal bug that resets custom targets immediately after saving, and Garmin and Fitbit sync failures that have been unresolved for over a year.
What is the best MyFitnessPal alternative in 2026?
For micronutrient depth: Cronometer. For simplicity: Lose It. For voice-first logging without database searching: Rekkon lets you say what you ate and estimates calories and macros from your description — no barcodes, no scrolling, no per-meal typing.
Seven days. See what it notices.
No barcodes. No databases. No meal plans. Just talk to it.
Try free