I downloaded MyFitnessPal in 2023 and used it almost every day for three years. I had streaks of 300+ days. I'd built up a library of custom meals. I knew exactly how to navigate the database, which version of "chicken breast" to trust, how to split a restaurant meal across entries.
And then one day I just stopped. Not because tracking stopped working. Because logging had become something I dreaded.
The thing nobody tells you about food databases
MyFitnessPal has over 14 million food entries. It sounds like more is better. In practice, it means that when you search "chicken wrap," you get 47 options, most created by different users with different assumptions, different portion sizes, and different levels of accuracy.
"I typed in 1 cup cooked quinoa and saw search results ranging from 120 calories to 225. People just write in their opinions. It defeats the purpose of counting calories." — App Store review
The database problem compounds over time. You learn which entries to trust. You develop workarounds. You find yourself spending four minutes logging a meal that took you twelve minutes to eat. The cognitive overhead becomes real.
The paywall creep
When I started with MFP, barcode scanning was free. Then it wasn't. Then Premium was $49/year. Then $79. The features I relied on kept migrating behind the paywall, and the free experience kept degrading. By 2025 the free version barely showed macros without a Premium prompt.
The redesigns that kept making things harder
In October 2025, MFP pushed an update that collapsed meal entries by default and removed copy-paste. In April 2026, they buried the entire food diary behind a "View All" button. Both times, the official response was some version of "we hear your feedback and are continuing to improve the experience."
The experience did not improve.
What I actually needed
Looking back, what made me stick with MFP for three years wasn't the database. It was awareness. The simple act of logging made me think about what I was eating. It created a feedback loop between intention and behaviour.
The database was the mechanism, but it was never really the point. The point was: do I know what I'm putting in my body today?
The research on logging consistency
Studies on habit formation consistently show that friction kills consistency. When the act of tracking becomes more burdensome than the behaviour it's meant to support, people stop. Most MFP users quit within two weeks. The people who stick with it long-term are the ones who've minimised the per-meal effort.
So I built something else
That's why Rekkon exists. No database. No barcode. You just say what you ate — "three slices of leftover pizza and a juice" — and it works out the rest. Then you can ask it anything. "I'm going out for drinks tonight, how much room do I have?" It answers based on what you've actually eaten today.
After a week it knows your patterns. After a month, the coaching gets specific. Not "eat more protein" — but "your weekday breakfasts are solid, the weekend ones are where the calories are hiding."
The database was never the moat. The coaching is.
Common questions
Why do people quit MyFitnessPal?
The most common reasons are logging friction — database searching takes 2 to 4 minutes per meal — paywall creep as features like barcode scanning moved behind Premium, and redesigns that made the app harder to use. Most calorie tracking users quit within two weeks.
Is there a food tracker that does not require database searching?
Yes. Voice-first apps like Rekkon let you describe what you ate in natural language — for example, three slices of leftover pizza and a juice — and estimate the calories and macros automatically. No database searching or barcode scanning required.
Does food tracking actually work for weight loss?
Yes, but consistency matters more than precision. Studies on habit formation show that the main driver of abandonment is friction. Apps that reduce per-meal logging time below 30 seconds have significantly higher retention than database-driven trackers.
Seven days. See what it notices.
No barcodes. No databases. No meal plans. Just talk to it.
Try free